Donald Lowry and British Loyalty in Empire
Donal Lowry, in his article The Crown, Empire Loyalism and the Assimilation of Non- British White Subjects in the British World: An Argument Against ‘Ethic Determinism’, attempts to challenge the previous imperial historiography that claims that British citizens and their descendants expressed little loyalty towards the British crown and empire. He argues that, in fact, some non-British citizens exhibited a fervor for empire just as genuine as that of the British settler loyalists and their descendants in the colonies. To prove this, the author primarily focuses on the Catholic communities of the settler colonies like Canada and Australia, but also discusses Jewish loyalism.
One of the arguments that Lowry makes is that for many non-British ethnic minorities, loyalty to the crown was not only a necessary defensive measure (“George-etienne
Cartier subsequently became fearful of the threat to property of the ideas of Proudhon and other socialists”) but also presented an opportunity to further their own nationalist interests (“Lafontaine became convinced that french-Canadian heritage would be best consolidated under the crown”). Another theme of the article is religion, which Lowry argues was prominent in consolidating empire loyalism of the non-British subjects in Canada and elsewhere. The crown became a guarantor of religious rights that french-Canadian bishops could depend on, at the time of the “misery and shame of the French Revolution.”
Many non-British subjects even became willing participants in the imperial project as they sought to spread the reach of their catholic religion to the rest of the empire. In other words, the author seems to suggest that as more time passed, the more the non-British populations in the colonies became loyal to the empire, as they sought to appropriate it for their own advantage. Another theme that is introduced in the article is the discord that exists in the ethnic communities regarding their role within the empire and loyalty to it.
While Lowry demonstrates the great contribution that ethnic communities like the Irish Catholics have made to the empire (D’arcy McGee), he also discusses their constant struggles in forging their own identities and the place it ought to occupy within the empire. Henri Bourassa for example, while fearing the threat of potential American annexation, also spoke of U.S. “aggressive imperialism” and the threat this posed to the french nation.
Lowry goes a long way in demonstrating the enthusiasm of many members of the non-British ethnic minorities for empire, as well as their important historical contributions to it. No one can doubt that many Irish Catholics or french-Canadians were willing imperialists and fiercely loyal to the crown. But Lowry, despite a few sparse reminders of the prevalence of French-Canadian nationalism (“monarchist sentiments were greatly weakened by the quiet revolution”), over-emphasizes the empire loyalism that was prevalent at the time. The majority of the sources, secondary in nature, tend to concentrate on the political elites of the non-British peoples. Very few references are made to the loyalty of average citizens, notwithstanding the popularity of the monarchical visits to Montreal and Toronto, hardly evidence of a profound “sense of loyalty to the crown and empire.”
In order to explain empire loyalism, Lowry refers to adoptive nationalism, where “the
monarchy could be imagined selectively by...imperial subjects.” He goes on to see traces of French-Canadian loyalty to empire in as late as 2001. Certainly, this is a redundant argument not worth mentioning. If a modern Quebec MP is making deference to the British monarchical heritage of the Canadian political system, is this truly a genuine loyalism to the British crown or rather mere sentimentalism? If Quebec were to have successfully gained independence, would its first task be to appoint a governor-general? Is it not more likely that immigrant arrivals adopt the prevailing nationalism, but without necessarily sensing a profound duty to a distant Queen?
It is this weakness that pervades Lowry’s earlier analysis of empire loyalism in the 19th and 20th centuries. The author fails to show that empire loyalism, where presumably the subject peoples were prepared to defend the crown in combat if necessary, was anything more than a sentiment present in the minority of the political elite or population as a whole.
Showing posts with label Canadian History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Canadian History. Show all posts
Sunday, August 26, 2007
Saturday, August 25, 2007
American Culture in Canada - Early 1900's
The American Cultural Invasion of Canada - Early 1900’s
Since the Great War, the Canadian relationship to the British Empire had been slowly evolving, being reduced in importance by the presence of American influence in Canada. Some even started talking about the imperialism of the United States, “economic in character” and where its control was diffused and gradual, making it difficult to assess.
In economic terms, according to the statistics compiled by the Canadian Department of Trade and Commerce, Canadian imports from the U.S. had been steadily increasing, reaching 69% in 1929. While Canadian imports from the United Kingdom, for example, had decreased to a low of 15% by the same year. In his dissertation on Canadian opposition to American empire,” John Weaver has shown how the aggressive economic policies of Herbert Hoover in the United States created and sustained a vast bureaucratic machine to exploit opportunity in Canada, thereby explaining the new trade relation between Canada and the U.S. But all British Dominions like Canada also were made vulnerable to encroachments from other countries due to the weakened state of the imperial center in Britain, a result of the Great War.
But other historical factors played a role as well such as the Alaska Boundary dispute. American economic dominance in Canada was just one variant of the ever changing dynamic between these two neighbors. Cultural penetration of the United States into Canada, especially in terms of popular literature and books, was another. As early as in 1912, for example, the import magazine market in Canada was monopolized by the United States to the degree of 90%, as opposed to British magazines making up a mere 7% of the marketplace.
After the war, the death knell for British magazines in Canada was accelerated: wartime disruptions had resulted in increased prices among other things compared to the price of their American equivalents. American magazines became so pervasive that for some, whole cities “beheld the imprint of the Unites States.”
Since the Great War, the Canadian relationship to the British Empire had been slowly evolving, being reduced in importance by the presence of American influence in Canada. Some even started talking about the imperialism of the United States, “economic in character” and where its control was diffused and gradual, making it difficult to assess.
In economic terms, according to the statistics compiled by the Canadian Department of Trade and Commerce, Canadian imports from the U.S. had been steadily increasing, reaching 69% in 1929. While Canadian imports from the United Kingdom, for example, had decreased to a low of 15% by the same year. In his dissertation on Canadian opposition to American empire,” John Weaver has shown how the aggressive economic policies of Herbert Hoover in the United States created and sustained a vast bureaucratic machine to exploit opportunity in Canada, thereby explaining the new trade relation between Canada and the U.S. But all British Dominions like Canada also were made vulnerable to encroachments from other countries due to the weakened state of the imperial center in Britain, a result of the Great War.
But other historical factors played a role as well such as the Alaska Boundary dispute. American economic dominance in Canada was just one variant of the ever changing dynamic between these two neighbors. Cultural penetration of the United States into Canada, especially in terms of popular literature and books, was another. As early as in 1912, for example, the import magazine market in Canada was monopolized by the United States to the degree of 90%, as opposed to British magazines making up a mere 7% of the marketplace.
After the war, the death knell for British magazines in Canada was accelerated: wartime disruptions had resulted in increased prices among other things compared to the price of their American equivalents. American magazines became so pervasive that for some, whole cities “beheld the imprint of the Unites States.”
Bill Deacon and Early Canadian Literature
Deacon's Early Literary Career
Canadian literary figure Bill Deacon had always considered himself to be a herald of Canadian talent. For Deacon, nurturing the nascent Canadian literary movement was “my self-appointed missionary work.” Of course, a larger tide of events was rolling along in Deacon's direction: The Copyright Bill (1919) and the Canadian Author's Association (1921). But if literary nationalism was the engine of a larger Canadian nationalism and concomitantly, in the further evaporation of Imperial sentiment, then Deacon would become the driving force behind literary nationalism; the need for a “new national self-consciousness.” In fact, Deacon's nationalism in many ways, did not mimic the trends of his time but rather led them. His nationalism was much more oppositional as well, always reacting to the American and British imperial overstretch.
The 1920's and thirties represented for Deacon a great flurry of activity; as author and literary critic. Throughout, he would use his position as literary critic in Saturday Night magazine (1922-1928) and Globe and Mail as well as the many books he authored, to comment on both the “inwardly nation” and the “outwardly empire”, but always forging ahead with a call for a new national identity for himself and for Canada.
An example of this can be seen in the pages of Saturday Night. Writing on October 28, 1922, as the magazines new literary critic, Deacon would send out a passionate plea to readers to remember “that the movement is primarily patriotic, and only secondarily to help the native author. Will you do your part?” Deacon had earlier emphasized, in a not-so-veiled reference to the British Imperial influence, the need for supporting Canadian talent:
Deacon was writing this when Saturday night had yet to shed it's own imperial romanticization of Britain. In fact, Deacon's independence or intransigence, as some consider it, would cost him his job, as we shall see later.
Being a literary critic in Saturday Night magazine in the early 1920's presented a difficult task. Certainly, the magazine was a flourishing weekly that devoted more place to Canadian literature than most of its competitors. But the magazine remained conservative. Hector Charlesworth, legendary journalist, vociferously criticized “The Group of Seven” for what he saw as their lack of talent. The pages of Saturday Night themselves reflected the imperial sympathies of Canadians. A 1920 advertisement for the Canadian National Exhibition described it as “the Empire Triumphant.” An editorial in 1924, mimicking Charleworth's earlier views, criticized the Group of Seven painters as not depicting real art. In fact, as the editorial reveals, the artists' work is being embraced by the real imperialists in Britain as “emphatic design,” while the Canadian imperialists rejected their own fellow artists for “their harsh, uncompromising style...a school of painting not of the soil, but of the rock.”
But Deacon would ultimately succeed at the magazine. Bringing an enthusiasm for native literature unmatched by most, he developed a devoted audience. Deacon featured Canadian content front and center, expanded the magazine by creating a new standalone literary section and congratulated the Quebec government for the support it gave to its native writers. But Deacon's driving independence and enthusiasm cost him his job in 1928: he was forced to quit after failing to abide by length restrictions and the general editorial policies of his publisher.
The decade of the 1920's also saw Deacon publish numerous books, revealing his attitudes on both nationalism and imperialism. In his biography on the life and times of Peter Mcarthur (1923) Deacon lauded the poet for his “cleverness and literary skill.” In reviewing “An Ode to Empire,” Deacon applaudes McArthur's avoidance of “banal expressions of cheap patriotic sentiment” and feels the need to justify this imperial sentiment by reminding us that mcArthur was the “only one to return to live among us.” In the same year, Ryerson Press published Deacon's Pens and Pirates, a collection of essays. In “The genial Profession,” a comedic piece that some have compared to Leacock's Sunshine Sketches, Deacon's writing style creates an imagery that duly expresses his views of imperial sentiment. Through repetition - “I serve, I have served, must serve” - and by utilizing the language of Empire itself - “Your majesty, darling of the Empire, Royal family” - Deacon successfully offers a mocking a portrayal of Canadian imperial sentiment.
At other times, Deacon was more compromising . In “Heritage and Destiny,” typical of his oft romantic and passionate prose, Deacon exhorts to Canadians that “with the English tradition in our memories, and the blood of the English pirates in our veins,” there can be nothing traitorous in the suggestion that we “loot these richly-laden argosies of English literature, boldly taking what we want and leaving acknowledgments for the hereafter.” In “the National Character,” Deacon reveals, whether consciously or not, the intangible and often arbitrary basis of his nationalism, by referring to a humorous anecdote:
Pens and Pirates, while well received by reviewers, sold abysmally25. This under lied Deacon's view of himself as a herald, one that remained both a pioneer of Canadian culture and on the outside to it. Deacon's next book, Poteen,: A Pot-Pourri of Canadian Essays,” dealt more overtly with the political issues of his time, such as the debate over American annexation, or Continentalism.
Canadian literary figure Bill Deacon had always considered himself to be a herald of Canadian talent. For Deacon, nurturing the nascent Canadian literary movement was “my self-appointed missionary work.” Of course, a larger tide of events was rolling along in Deacon's direction: The Copyright Bill (1919) and the Canadian Author's Association (1921). But if literary nationalism was the engine of a larger Canadian nationalism and concomitantly, in the further evaporation of Imperial sentiment, then Deacon would become the driving force behind literary nationalism; the need for a “new national self-consciousness.” In fact, Deacon's nationalism in many ways, did not mimic the trends of his time but rather led them. His nationalism was much more oppositional as well, always reacting to the American and British imperial overstretch.
The 1920's and thirties represented for Deacon a great flurry of activity; as author and literary critic. Throughout, he would use his position as literary critic in Saturday Night magazine (1922-1928) and Globe and Mail as well as the many books he authored, to comment on both the “inwardly nation” and the “outwardly empire”, but always forging ahead with a call for a new national identity for himself and for Canada.
An example of this can be seen in the pages of Saturday Night. Writing on October 28, 1922, as the magazines new literary critic, Deacon would send out a passionate plea to readers to remember “that the movement is primarily patriotic, and only secondarily to help the native author. Will you do your part?” Deacon had earlier emphasized, in a not-so-veiled reference to the British Imperial influence, the need for supporting Canadian talent:
“Every foreign book is written from the author's national standpoint; it carries subtle, and generally, unconscious propaganda in its very atmosphere. Foreign influences are broadening ...At present it is not only unnecessary, it is a positive danger to a healthy nationalism.”
Deacon was writing this when Saturday night had yet to shed it's own imperial romanticization of Britain. In fact, Deacon's independence or intransigence, as some consider it, would cost him his job, as we shall see later.
Being a literary critic in Saturday Night magazine in the early 1920's presented a difficult task. Certainly, the magazine was a flourishing weekly that devoted more place to Canadian literature than most of its competitors. But the magazine remained conservative. Hector Charlesworth, legendary journalist, vociferously criticized “The Group of Seven” for what he saw as their lack of talent. The pages of Saturday Night themselves reflected the imperial sympathies of Canadians. A 1920 advertisement for the Canadian National Exhibition described it as “the Empire Triumphant.” An editorial in 1924, mimicking Charleworth's earlier views, criticized the Group of Seven painters as not depicting real art. In fact, as the editorial reveals, the artists' work is being embraced by the real imperialists in Britain as “emphatic design,” while the Canadian imperialists rejected their own fellow artists for “their harsh, uncompromising style...a school of painting not of the soil, but of the rock.”
But Deacon would ultimately succeed at the magazine. Bringing an enthusiasm for native literature unmatched by most, he developed a devoted audience. Deacon featured Canadian content front and center, expanded the magazine by creating a new standalone literary section and congratulated the Quebec government for the support it gave to its native writers. But Deacon's driving independence and enthusiasm cost him his job in 1928: he was forced to quit after failing to abide by length restrictions and the general editorial policies of his publisher.
The decade of the 1920's also saw Deacon publish numerous books, revealing his attitudes on both nationalism and imperialism. In his biography on the life and times of Peter Mcarthur (1923) Deacon lauded the poet for his “cleverness and literary skill.” In reviewing “An Ode to Empire,” Deacon applaudes McArthur's avoidance of “banal expressions of cheap patriotic sentiment” and feels the need to justify this imperial sentiment by reminding us that mcArthur was the “only one to return to live among us.” In the same year, Ryerson Press published Deacon's Pens and Pirates, a collection of essays. In “The genial Profession,” a comedic piece that some have compared to Leacock's Sunshine Sketches, Deacon's writing style creates an imagery that duly expresses his views of imperial sentiment. Through repetition - “I serve, I have served, must serve” - and by utilizing the language of Empire itself - “Your majesty, darling of the Empire, Royal family” - Deacon successfully offers a mocking a portrayal of Canadian imperial sentiment.
At other times, Deacon was more compromising . In “Heritage and Destiny,” typical of his oft romantic and passionate prose, Deacon exhorts to Canadians that “with the English tradition in our memories, and the blood of the English pirates in our veins,” there can be nothing traitorous in the suggestion that we “loot these richly-laden argosies of English literature, boldly taking what we want and leaving acknowledgments for the hereafter.” In “the National Character,” Deacon reveals, whether consciously or not, the intangible and often arbitrary basis of his nationalism, by referring to a humorous anecdote:
“Two workmen quarrelled. On had come here from England two years before, the other six months. The two-year individual sought for a final epithet, and shot his crowning insult – 'You damned Englishman!'”
Pens and Pirates, while well received by reviewers, sold abysmally25. This under lied Deacon's view of himself as a herald, one that remained both a pioneer of Canadian culture and on the outside to it. Deacon's next book, Poteen,: A Pot-Pourri of Canadian Essays,” dealt more overtly with the political issues of his time, such as the debate over American annexation, or Continentalism.
Imperial Sentiment In Early 20th Century Canada
Imperial Sentiment In early 20th century Canada
In order to understand the extent of the influence of the imperial factor in Canada, one can briefly look at the post-war sentiment that existed after the American revolution, where U.S. Citizens immediately and unrelentingly sought to build a national character that permanently severed ties to the motherland. Yet for Canadians, despite a post-confederation moment of crisis - “when Canadians looked inward, fully engrossed with their internal problems,” - the imperial sentiment remained strong.
This is most obvious in the late 1890's, with the rise of the New Imperialism in Canada. With the coming of the Boer War and influenced by Victorian idealism, many in English Canada actively linked Christian missionary activity with the aggressive, secular economic imperialism, therefore obviating any critical response to the excesses of empire; as a result, “British supremacy” was logically seen as “the only route to lasting peace” in Southern Africa. This new imperialism received a boost from Canadian George Parkin, a teacher and lecturer. Parkin published a map of the British Empire that sought to visualize and reinforce the the many ties that existed among the various constituents of that empire.
Others have qualified the imperial sentiment of early 20th century Canada by referring to a “North Atlantic Triangle;” one where the “interrelationships of Canada, the U.S. and Britain has had an important impact on the histories of all these countries...where Canada relied upon British might and prestige to counter American military economic encroachments.” Notwithstanding the American factor, Mackenzie's analysis is in line with the rise of Neo-imperialism during this era. Again, this is not to deny the existence of a Canadian national sentiment and identity: it certainly did exist in literature for example. Indeed, William Arthur deacon would find a rich heritage to build upon for his own work as promoter of Canadian literature.
The Confederation Poets, part of the larger Canada first Movement, produced widely heralded native poetics. Montgomery's Anne of Green Gables (1908), Leacock's musings in Sunshine Sketches of a little Town (1912), and poet Emile Nelligan in Quebec all reflected domestic and unique Canadian themes. But the outward imperial sentiment that was operating on a hegemonic level - “an ethical state of mind10” - went a long way in explaining the necessity for someone like Bill Deacon. Even the Canadian nationalists, while rejecting an enforced role “as granary of the empire” by Britain, sought to join the “Mother country in its cosmopolitan intercourse” with the world. Admittedly, Canadian contribution to, or some would say losses in the Great War had a large role in realigning patriotic sentiment inwardly.
Even then, as Philip Buckner has tried to argue, there is no conclusive evidence that a plurality of Canadians demanded an end to the Imperial relationship in the inter war period.
In order to understand the extent of the influence of the imperial factor in Canada, one can briefly look at the post-war sentiment that existed after the American revolution, where U.S. Citizens immediately and unrelentingly sought to build a national character that permanently severed ties to the motherland. Yet for Canadians, despite a post-confederation moment of crisis - “when Canadians looked inward, fully engrossed with their internal problems,” - the imperial sentiment remained strong.
This is most obvious in the late 1890's, with the rise of the New Imperialism in Canada. With the coming of the Boer War and influenced by Victorian idealism, many in English Canada actively linked Christian missionary activity with the aggressive, secular economic imperialism, therefore obviating any critical response to the excesses of empire; as a result, “British supremacy” was logically seen as “the only route to lasting peace” in Southern Africa. This new imperialism received a boost from Canadian George Parkin, a teacher and lecturer. Parkin published a map of the British Empire that sought to visualize and reinforce the the many ties that existed among the various constituents of that empire.
Others have qualified the imperial sentiment of early 20th century Canada by referring to a “North Atlantic Triangle;” one where the “interrelationships of Canada, the U.S. and Britain has had an important impact on the histories of all these countries...where Canada relied upon British might and prestige to counter American military economic encroachments.” Notwithstanding the American factor, Mackenzie's analysis is in line with the rise of Neo-imperialism during this era. Again, this is not to deny the existence of a Canadian national sentiment and identity: it certainly did exist in literature for example. Indeed, William Arthur deacon would find a rich heritage to build upon for his own work as promoter of Canadian literature.
The Confederation Poets, part of the larger Canada first Movement, produced widely heralded native poetics. Montgomery's Anne of Green Gables (1908), Leacock's musings in Sunshine Sketches of a little Town (1912), and poet Emile Nelligan in Quebec all reflected domestic and unique Canadian themes. But the outward imperial sentiment that was operating on a hegemonic level - “an ethical state of mind10” - went a long way in explaining the necessity for someone like Bill Deacon. Even the Canadian nationalists, while rejecting an enforced role “as granary of the empire” by Britain, sought to join the “Mother country in its cosmopolitan intercourse” with the world. Admittedly, Canadian contribution to, or some would say losses in the Great War had a large role in realigning patriotic sentiment inwardly.
Even then, as Philip Buckner has tried to argue, there is no conclusive evidence that a plurality of Canadians demanded an end to the Imperial relationship in the inter war period.
William Arthur Deacon

Biography of William Arthur Deacon
Bill Deacon was born in Pembroke, Ontario, in 1890. The son of a lawyer and practicing nurse, his family heritage would play an important role in the development of Deacon's intense nationalism later on in life. In fact, it is no exaggeration to say that Deacon's experiences in his early years were the most formative of his entire life.
Until 1907, Deacon lived in Stanstead, Quebec attending the main college there. Located in the eastern townships and within the close range of the American border, Stanstead offered Deacon an initial, if not brief, exposure to Canada's southern neighbor. Deacon credited his early education at Stanstead for igniting an intense love of of his country - “a Canadian nationalist was born 57 years go. I am he” - and equal love of Canadian literature: “I was thrilled and listened so intently...because this eloquent man, reading these Canadian poems, told me what it was to be Canadian.1” While Deacon's love of all things Canadian can be traced to Stanstead College, his life-log antithesis to an overbearing British imperial hegemony can be said to have begun in his early school years. After graduating, Deacon went on to Victoria College in Toronto, where his newfound Canadian sensibilities were faced squarely against the old British heritage of the school environment.
In particular, Deacon came to resent one of his particular teachers, the English department head Pelham Edgar, because as he later explained to Emily Murphy, “I know him to be an aper of the English gentleman, he can never forget that his mother was Lady Edgar.2” One final experience that laid the foundation for Deacon's subsequent life and career choices was the doctrine of Theosophy. Briefly explained, this was a philosophical system based on the fundamental and eternal qualities of truth that are common to all. With mystical overtones similar to those of many eastern religions, Theosophy would instill in Deacon a life-long sense of duty and mission, a mission that would find its apex in Canadian literature.
These early years then set the tone for Deacon's later decisions in life. In William Arthur deacon: a Canadian Literary Life, biographers Clara Thomas and John Lennox have argued that from Deacon's graduation at Victoria until his completion of his law degree at the University of Manitoba (that is roughly from 1910-1918), these were the years that “were crucial in his choice of a life-long philosophy and a life's work.3” While it is hard to contradict this argument, since Deacon's awareness of Theosophy occurred during this time, it should be remembered that his most formative experiences (as it will be reflected in later years) had their roots before 1910. Deacon's family history of which he was very proud , included some four generations of lawyers and the College which he attended at Stanstead had a long tradition of its own since its founding in 1829. Both of these factors conspired to instill in Deacon a deep sense of connection to the local history, land and culture of his surroundings. In other words, Canada and not the British empire, became the preeminent source of Deacon's inspiration, a local anchor for his nascent sense of identity and nationalism.
Writing in 1953, Deacon looked back at his career and expressed his satisfaction at having been intended “to play nursemaid to Canadian literature...I regard this country as important and therefore its writers as very important.4” Deacon was reflecting on early 20th century Canada, a time when society did not give enough value to its own writers and poets - “they have no respect for literary natives here unless they made their mark abroad5” - an argument that continues to hold significance in more modern times. In fact, for many Canadians, the cultural and political orientation which they expressed pointed, similar to that of Deacon's early English teacher at Victoria, towards the British Empire. The Imperial sentiment, arguably expressing itself more on a culturally hegemonic level than on a daily personal level of individual Canadians, was nonetheless an important orientating factor for Canadian identity and values.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)